| || |
"Helping you to help your ADD ADHD child"by Anthony Kane, MD
|ADD ADHD||ADHD Articles||ADHD Resources||Links||About Us||Contact Us|
The Use of Brain SPECT Imaging in ADHDby Anthony Kane, MD
For an website send an email to:
The ProblemWhen a person has a broken leg the orthopedic surgeon takes an x-ray. This tells him the exact nature of the brake and how best to treat it. When a patient has a heart problem the cardiologist performs a cardiac catheterization study. The doctor sees the exact area of the obstruction and knows how best to treat it. When a patient needs a tumor removed the surgeon will order a CT scan or an MRI scan so he has an exact image of the disease before he takes the person to surgery. Almost every medical specialty relies on some type of imaging test so that the physician can visualize the problem and plan the best course of action for his patient.
The brain is the most complex structure in the known universe. Yet even more perplexing than its physical intricacy is the complexity with which it functions. CT scans and MRI scans can give the physician a clear picture of the physical structure of the brain. EEG can give a crude picture of the electrical activity of the brain. Yet unlike most other areas of medicine, psychiatry has no real way to visualize its specialty’s focus, brain function. When it comes to treating disorders of brain function, such as Bipolar disorder or Oppositional Defiant Disorder, psychiatrists are working in the dark. They are dealing with the most complex aspect of the most complicated structure in the universe, but they have no way to visualize the problems.
What is Brain SPECT imaging
SPECT can identify specifically which areas of the patient’s brain are overactive, which are functioning normally, and which areas are not working well. This information, combined with what we know about the function the specific areas of the brain, can give the clinician a very clear picture of exactly what is going on. This information along with a detailed clinical history, can give the psychiatrist a detailed picture of the physiological cause of the problem he is treating. This in turn can help him to pinpoint the best treatment to balance brain function.
Generally, the procedure for ADHD is run twice in a four-day period. The first study images the patient at rest. This gives the clinician a baseline view of the patient’s brain function. For the second scan, the patient is given a concentration task. This gives an image of the brain when it is actively working and helps to identify areas of dysfunction during performance.
AdvantagesBrain SPECT scans give an accurate picture brain activity. When combined with our knowledge of what function various areas of the brain serve, this information can lead to a much more accurate diagnosis.
In addition SPECT can help guide treatment. The current state of the art method in psychiatric treatment is guessing. Now these guesses are educated guesses, so they are usually pretty good, but they are still guesses.
For example, when a psychiatrist sees a child who is hyperactive, inattentive, and impulsive, he gets a “clinical impression” that this child has ADHD. He knows that more than 90% of ADHD children will improve with drugs like Ritalin. For this patient Ritalin is a very good guess, so the psychiatrist prescribes Ritalin. So what does the doctor do when Ritalin doesn’t work? He makes another guess. However, this usually won’t happen in children who have the classic ADHD symptoms.
However, say the psychiatrist sees a second child, who is very hyperactive and aggressive, but he doesn’t seem to have an attention problem. This is not the typical ADD ADHD child. The psychiatrist may still feel that Ritalin is the best guess, but this choice is not quite as good as it is for the first child. It is much more likely to fail and the psychiatrist will need to spend months or years trying different things until he hits upon a combination that helps this child. Often he will settle for only a partial relief of symptoms.
Now let’s say the physician had done brain SPECT imaging on this second child and he identifies a defect in temporal lobe function. He knows that this area of the brain responds well to Valproic acid, a drug that is seldom used for ADHD, and that is what he prescribes. Without the brain SPECT imaging, the psychiatrist may never have made the proper guess and found the optimal treatment to help this child to function normally. However, with the brain SPECT scan he would know exactly how to treat this child.
DisadvantagesThe main problem with SPECT imaging is the cost is very high. A complete evaluation is about $3000 and is usually not covered by most insurance plans.
Also, there is limited access to this test. Brain SPECT imaging for psychiatric diagnosis has not been embraced by mainstream medicine. Unless you live in one of the few areas in the country where this test is done, you are going to have to take a small vacation.
Finally, we still only have a minimal amount of information to connect specific brain function defects to clinical behavior. We still need a lot more research before this will become a really useful technique, and considering the degree of opposition this is going to take a while.
What’s Holding Things Back To say that Brain SPEC imaging is in its infancy would be an exaggeration. It is more like it is in its fetal stage; and there are numbers of physicians who have been trying to abort this baby.
Most psychiatrists balk at the idea of using an imaging study to make what they feel is purely a clinical diagnosis. They feel that Dr. Amen has greatly overstressed the value of this technique. As one well known psychiatrist puts it, “If it were really worth it, don’t you think that Harvard and Yale would be using it?”
With this type of attitude it is amazing that the field has gotten anywhere. However, Dr. Amen has slowly made progress over the last decade and now many former opponents are entertaining the idea that brain SPECT imaging may have some value.
ConclusionWe are still a long way from realizing the full benefit of brain SPECT imaging. It is not yet a refined diagnostic tool for psychiatric disorders. It is also expensive and inconvenient.
Although there are a few places in the United States that do this test, Dr. Amen is still the only practitioner with any significant experience. Probably you are going to eventually have to go to him and pay the price in time and money. However, for children who do not respond to conventional treatment, I feel that brain SPECT imaging may have a lot to offer.
Anthony Kane, MD
ADD ADHD Advances
If you want more information on ways that you can teach even the most difficult child to obey you, please see our
If you want more information on ways that you can help your ADHD child get off medication then please see our